How Many Honors Classes Should a Freshman Take?
How many AP and Honors classes should a freshman take? There is no universal number. A freshman should take the most challenging courses they can manage successfully while maintaining strong grades, healthy study habits, and time for activities outside the classroom. For some students, that may mean several Honors classes; for others, one or two—or even none—may be the better choice. AP availability and eligibility also vary by high school. The goal is not to maximize the number of advanced courses, but to build an appropriately challenging schedule that supports long-term academic growth.
Freshman year brings plenty of decisions, but one of the biggest comes before the first day of school: How challenging should your teenager’s course schedule be?
Should they take every honors class available? Is one AP class enough? Will choosing a standard-level course hurt their college options later?
I understand why parents ask these questions. I’ve spent 15 years working in education consulting, and I know how much attention families pay to academic rigor.
But I’ve also learned something from being the dad of twin daughters: the schedule that looks strongest on paper isn’t necessarily the schedule that works best for the student living it.
I learned that lesson firsthand with Honors Geometry.
I encouraged both of my daughters to take an accelerated summer Honors Geometry course. I saw an opportunity to get ahead academically. What I didn’t fully appreciate was that the same opportunity could be a very different experience for each girl.
One daughter ultimately left the course after we talked it through and agreed it wasn’t the right fit at that moment. The other stayed, worked through the challenges, and earned a B.
Same family. Same course. Two different outcomes.
Neither decision was a failure.
That experience changed how I think about a question parents ask all the time:
How many AP and honors classes should a freshman take?
The answer isn’t a magic number. It’s a process for finding the right level of challenge.

1. Start With What Your High School Actually Offers
Before counting honors or AP courses, understand the options available at your teenager’s school.
High schools vary considerably. One may offer several honors classes to freshmen. Another may reserve most advanced courses for sophomores and juniors. Some schools offer AP Human Geography in ninth grade; others offer no freshman AP courses at all.
That’s why comparing your student’s schedule to a teenager at another school can be misleading.
Start with three documents:
- The course catalog: What courses can freshmen actually take, and what prerequisites apply?
- The graduation requirements: Which subjects and sequences must students complete?
- The school profile: How does the school describe its curriculum, grading, and academic opportunities to colleges?
Then map out the options by subject.
| Subject | Standard option | Advanced option | What to clarify |
|---|---|---|---|
| English | English 9 | Honors English 9 | Reading and writing workload |
| Math | Grade-appropriate sequence | Accelerated or honors sequence | Prerequisites and future math options |
| Science | Biology or another introductory course | Honors Biology | Lab work, pace, and expected preparation |
| Social studies | Standard freshman course | Honors or AP option, if offered | Reading, writing, and independent study demands |
| World language | Appropriate language level | Accelerated or advanced level | Placement and prior proficiency |
This table is an illustration, not a universal freshman curriculum.
The first question isn’t “How many advanced classes should my freshman take?” It’s “Which advanced classes are actually available and appropriate at this school?”
2. Understand the Difference Between Honors and AP
Parents sometimes talk about honors and AP classes as if they’re interchangeable. They’re not.
Honors courses are generally designed and defined by the school or district. They may move faster, go deeper, require more independent work, or cover additional material. But what “honors” means can vary from school to school.
Advanced Placement (AP) courses follow a College Board course framework and are designed to offer college-level study in a high school setting. Students may also choose to take an AP exam.
AP classes are not universally available to freshmen, and many students benefit from building a strong academic foundation before taking them. The College Board notes that AP courses are rarely offered in ninth grade and encourages schools to consider whether younger students have the academic foundation needed for college-level coursework.
The important question is not whether AP is automatically better than honors.
It’s whether the course is a sensible next step for your student.
For example, a freshman who enjoys history, reads independently, and writes comfortably may be ready for an available AP social studies course.
A student who is still adjusting to high-school reading and writing expectations might be better served by a strong honors or standard-level class.
Neither choice should be made just to improve the appearance of a transcript.
3. Evaluate Readiness by Subject, Not by Overall GPA
One of the most common mistakes in academic planning is assuming that a student who earns strong grades should take advanced classes in every subject.
But academic strengths aren’t always evenly distributed.
A teenager might be an excellent math student who struggles with lengthy reading assignments. Another might be a confident writer who needs more time to master new science concepts.
That’s normal.
I recommend evaluating each potential advanced course across four dimensions.
A student’s interests can also help guide course selection. Before choosing advanced classes simply because they’re available, consider exploring which subjects and potential career paths genuinely interest your teenager. Our career exploration guide for high school students offers a practical starting point.
Academic Foundation
Does your teenager have the prerequisite knowledge and skills?
For an advanced math course, that might mean a solid grasp of previous math concepts—not simply a high grade earned with extensive tutoring or repeated retakes.
For honors English, it might mean being comfortable reading independently, developing arguments, and revising written work.
Independence
Can your student manage assignments, seek help, and recover when something doesn’t make sense immediately?
Advanced courses often require more than understanding the material. They require the ability to keep moving when the work becomes difficult.
Genuine Interest
Does your teenager actually enjoy the subject?
Interest isn’t mandatory, but it can make challenging work more sustainable.
A student who loves science may willingly spend extra time on a difficult lab report. That same student may find an equally demanding reading assignment exhausting.
Available Capacity
What else is happening in your teenager’s life?
Sports, music, clubs, family responsibilities, friendships, and the general adjustment to high school all compete for time and attention.
A student can be academically capable of taking an advanced course without having enough capacity to take five of them simultaneously.
4. Try a Simple Course-Readiness Check
Here’s a practical exercise you can do with your teenager.
For each advanced course under consideration, rate these four areas from 1 to 3.
| Factor | 1 | 2 | 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Academic foundation | Needs significant support | Generally prepared | Strongly prepared |
| Independence | Needs frequent reminders | Usually self-managing | Consistently independent |
| Interest | Little interest | Some interest | Strong interest |
| Available capacity | Already stretched | Some room | Plenty of room |
Imagine a student considering Honors Biology.
- Academic foundation: 3
- Independence: 2
- Interest: 3
- Available capacity: 2
Total: 10 out of 12
That suggests a promising fit worth discussing.
But here’s an important qualification: this is a conversation tool, not a scientifically validated readiness test. A score of 10 doesn’t guarantee success, and a score of 7 doesn’t automatically mean a student shouldn’t enroll.
The individual ratings often tell you more than the total.
For example, if a student scores high on academic foundation but low on available capacity, the issue may not be whether they can handle Honors Biology.
It may be whether they can handle Honors Biology alongside everything else.
That’s a different problem—and it may have a different solution.
5. Look at the Entire Schedule, Not Just Individual Classes
A course can make sense by itself and still be the wrong addition to an already demanding schedule.
This is where parents need to move beyond course labels and think about time.
Consider an illustrative freshman week:
| Commitment | Hours per week |
|---|---|
| School and commuting | 40 |
| Sports, clubs, or other activities | 10 |
| Family responsibilities and commitments | 5 |
| Homework and studying | 12–15 |
| Total scheduled commitments | 67–70 |
Those numbers are examples, not a recommended schedule. They also don’t include sleep, meals, personal care, or downtime.
For teenagers ages 13–17, the CDC recommends 8–10 hours of sleep per 24 hours.
Now imagine that adding an honors course creates another two hours of homework each week. That might be manageable.
But if three advanced courses each add two hours, that’s six additional hours that need to come from somewhere.
Maybe the student has that time. Maybe they don’t.
Before adding a course, ask:
What will this class require, and what will my teenager have to give up to make room for it?
Don’t rely solely on course titles. Ask teachers or counselors about the actual workload at your school.
And don’t overlook the value of unstructured time. Freshmen need room to adjust, socialize, make mistakes, and occasionally do nothing.
6. Think Four Years Ahead—Without Planning Every Minute
Freshman-year course choices can affect later options, particularly in subjects with strict sequences.
Math is a good example.
At some schools, students might follow pathways resembling these:
| Grade | Accelerated example | Standard example |
|---|---|---|
| 9 | Honors Geometry | Algebra I |
| 10 | Honors Algebra II | Geometry |
| 11 | Precalculus | Algebra II |
| 12 | Calculus or Statistics | Precalculus or Statistics |
Actual course sequences vary by district, placement, and prerequisites. Some students start in different places or take summer courses.
The point isn’t that every teenager needs calculus by senior year.
It’s that parents should understand which doors a course choice opens, closes, or simply delays.
Ask the counselor:
- If my student takes this course now, what becomes available next year?
- If they take the standard course instead, can they move into an honors track later?
- Are there prerequisites or placement requirements we should know about?
- Is summer coursework necessary—or merely optional—to reach a particular pathway?
Plan with flexibility. Your ninth grader’s interests may change substantially before senior year.
7. What Might a Reasonable Freshman Schedule Look Like?
Let’s consider three hypothetical students.
These aren’t prescriptions. They’re examples of how the same decision framework can lead to different schedules.
Student A: Strong Across Subjects, With a Serious Sport Commitment
This student earns strong grades, works independently, and enjoys school. They also spend significant time practicing and competing.
A reasonable starting point might be three honors courses, selected in their strongest subjects, with standard-level courses elsewhere.
The deciding factor isn’t whether they’re smart enough for four or five advanced classes. It’s whether the overall workload remains sustainable during the sports season.
Student B: Strong in Math, Still Developing as a Writer
This student excels in math and enjoys science but needs more support with reading and essay writing.
A schedule with one or two advanced courses—perhaps honors math and science—might provide meaningful challenge without making every evening a struggle.
There is no benefit in treating every subject as though it requires the same level of acceleration.
Student C: Capable but Already Overcommitted
This student is academically strong but participates in several activities and has trouble managing deadlines.
They might choose two honors courses and focus on building better organizational habits before adding more advanced classes in sophomore year.
That’s not lowering expectations.
It’s making a strategic choice about timing.
These examples illustrate why a universal answer such as “every freshman should take three honors classes” isn’t especially useful.
8. What Do Colleges Actually Care About?
College admissions is one reason parents feel pressure to maximize advanced coursework.
Colleges often consider both academic performance and the rigor of the courses available to a student. But that doesn’t translate into a universal required number of honors or AP classes.
In NACAC’s Fall 2023 admissions survey, approximately 76.8% of responding colleges rated grades in college-preparatory courses as considerably important, while 63.8% gave that rating to strength of curriculum.
Those figures describe the survey respondents—not every college or a formula for admission.
They do reinforce an important point: colleges may care about both how a student performs and the academic opportunities they pursue.
Admissions offices can also consider school context. An applicant whose school offers few advanced courses should not be evaluated as though they had access to the same options as a student at a school offering many.
Parents often ask a version of this question:
Is a B in an honors course better than an A in a standard course?
There isn’t a universal answer.
It depends on the student, the subject, the school, the broader transcript, and the college’s evaluation process.
My advice is to avoid building a schedule around that comparison alone.
A teenager who develops strong skills, remains engaged, and progresses appropriately through challenging coursework is building something more valuable than a transcript designed around a single hypothetical admissions calculation.
9. Build in Reassessment Points
Choosing a schedule doesn’t mean you’re locked into your original assumptions.
Before school begins, find out your school’s deadlines for changing courses.
Then plan to check in at three points.
After the first three or four weeks: Is your teenager understanding the material? How much time is homework taking? Are they sleeping enough?
At the first grading period: Are the grades reflecting learning, or is the student constantly scrambling to keep up? Are activities and relationships still manageable?
Before the course-change deadline: If a class is clearly the wrong fit, what options are available?
These conversations should focus on patterns rather than a single disappointing quiz.
One difficult assignment doesn’t mean a student should leave an advanced course.
But weeks of mounting stress, lost sleep, and constant frustration deserve attention.
That’s part of what I wish I’d evaluated more carefully before encouraging my twins to take Honors Geometry.
10. Let Your Teenager Participate in the Decision
Parents can gather information and offer perspective, but our teenagers are the ones who will attend these classes every day.
I like asking questions that go beyond “Do you think you can handle it?”
Try these:
- Which subjects make you curious enough to do extra work?
- Which classes feel challenging in a good way, and which leave you drained?
- How much homework time do you think you can realistically manage?
- What activities or personal time matter enough that you want to protect them?
- If a class becomes harder than expected, what kind of support would you be willing to seek?
You may not get thoughtful answers to all five questions in one conversation.
That’s okay.
The goal is to give your teenager a meaningful voice in the decision—and help them begin taking ownership of their education.
11. Seven Questions to Ask Your School Counselor
A good counselor conversation can prevent a lot of guesswork.
Consider asking:
- Which advanced courses are actually available to freshmen?
- What distinguishes the honors version of a course from the standard version?
- How much additional homework should students realistically expect?
- What prerequisites or placement criteria apply?
- How do freshman choices affect sophomore, junior, and senior-year options?
- Can students move between standard and honors tracks later?
- What are the deadlines and policies for changing a course if the placement isn’t working?
The answers may reveal that your school’s options are more flexible—or more restrictive—than you assumed.
Either way, you’ll be making a more informed decision.
So, How Many AP and Honors Classes Should a Freshman Take?
Here’s the answer I would give a parent sitting across from me:
Take the number of advanced courses your student is prepared for, interested in, and able to manage within a balanced schedule.
At some schools, taking zero AP classes in ninth grade is completely normal because AP courses aren’t offered to freshmen.
At others, one carefully chosen AP course may make sense.
For honors courses, one or two may be the right fit for one student. Three or four may be reasonable for another. Some students may be better served by taking none.
Those are possibilities, not target numbers.
What matters is whether the schedule offers meaningful challenge without requiring your teenager to sacrifice sleep, well-being, or everything they enjoy outside the classroom.
The Consultant vs. The Dad
The consultant in me understands why families want a clear academic plan.
The dad in me has learned that a plan only works if it fits the child.
With my twins, I initially saw accelerated Honors Geometry as an opportunity worth pursuing for both of them.
What I eventually saw was that the right decision wasn’t the same for each daughter.
One stepped away. One stayed and earned a B.
Both experiences taught us something.
And that’s the lesson I keep coming back to as we navigate these four years:
We’re not trying to build the most impressive freshman schedule. We’re trying to build the right one.
Free AP & Honors Course Decision Worksheet
If you’re weighing advanced-course options for your own teenager, I’ve created a free, one-page worksheet to help.
It walks you through course options, academic readiness, weekly commitments, and the questions worth asking before registration.
Download the Free AP & Honors Course Decision Worksheet
Follow the Decisions
Two daughters. Two different paths. One dad learning as we go.
I’m an education consultant with 15 years of experience helping families navigate high school and college preparation. Now I’m doing it with my own twin daughters—and discovering that being the dad is a little different from being the consultant.
MaddKatt is where I share the decisions we’re making, the lessons we’re learning, and the occasional reminder that even someone who does this for a living doesn’t have all the answers.
Want to follow along? Join Follow the Decisions for occasional notes from our journey—the everyday moments, unexpected turns, and things worth sharing along the way.
As a welcome gift, I’ll send you The Freshman-Year Reality Check: 10 Conversations Worth Having With Your High Schooler.
By subscribing, you agree to receive occasional MaddKatt email updates. Your email address will be processed by MailerLite. Unsubscribe anytime. See our Privacy Policy.
