I Pushed My Twins Into Honors Geometry. Here’s What I Learned.

I encouraged both of my twins to take Honors Geometry over the summer. One dropped it. The other earned a B. What happened next changed how I'm approaching their high school years.

I should probably start this article with a confession.

I got it wrong.

Before my twin daughters officially started ninth grade, I did something I’ve advised parents against for years.

I chased rigor.

I encouraged both of my daughters to take Honors Geometry over the summer.

On paper, the plan looked good. They would complete Geometry before high school started, potentially benefit from weighted coursework, and keep more advanced math options open down the road.

As an education consultant, I could make a pretty compelling argument for that decision.

As a dad, I wanted my daughters to get ahead.

Those two motivations are not always as different as I’d like to admit.

Then summer started.

Both daughters spent day after day studying. Neither looked particularly happy about it.

At first, I told myself what I’m sure many parents have told themselves when watching their children struggle through something difficult:

It’ll all be worth it in the end.

But then the midterm grades came back.

And I saw the disappointment on their faces.

One daughter would eventually drop the course. The other would finish and earn a B.

Neither outcome was what I had imagined when I encouraged them to enroll.

And somewhere in the middle of that summer, I found myself questioning the very advice I’d been so confident about giving.

Microscope, graphing calculator, protractor, and compass arranged on a desk with school supplies.
The tools for tackling challenging classes are important. But as I learned with my twins, knowing when to push—and when to step back—matters just as much.

The Consultant in Me Had a Plan

When I looked at my daughters’ high school math trajectories, I saw an opportunity.

Complete Geometry early.

Keep advanced math options open.

Build a strong academic foundation.

None of those goals were unreasonable.

In fact, they’re the kinds of things I regularly discuss with families considering accelerated coursework.

But there’s a difference between identifying a good academic opportunity and deciding that opportunity is right for a particular student.

Somewhere along the way, I allowed “more rigorous” to become synonymous with “better.”

And those aren’t the same thing.

It’s a distinction I’ve made countless times when advising other parents.

Apparently, I needed to hear myself say it a little louder.

Then Summer Happened

Summer courses can be deceptively demanding.

Because regular school isn’t in session, it’s easy to assume students will have plenty of time to focus on one subject.

But a full course compressed into a shorter period moves quickly. There’s less time to absorb difficult concepts, less room to recover when something doesn’t click, and less opportunity to catch up before the next lesson arrives.

I understood all of that professionally.

What I hadn’t fully appreciated was what it would look like in my own house.

I watched both daughters study all day, every day.

Instead of enjoying their summer, they were spending much of it working through Geometry.

And neither seemed particularly happy.

In the beginning, I tried to reassure myself that the short-term sacrifice would lead to a long-term benefit.

They’d finish the course. They’d be ahead. We’d look back and feel that the hard work had been worthwhile.

Then came the midterm grades.

I remember seeing how disappointed they looked.

And suddenly, all those confident explanations I’d given myself didn’t seem quite so convincing.

The questions started coming.

Did I push them into this?

Should I have encouraged them to take regular Geometry instead of Honors?

Would a different summer course have been a better choice?

Or should they have taken no summer class at all?

I felt doubt.

And, if I’m being honest, some guilt.

Because whatever the outcome, I was the parent who had encouraged this plan in the first place.

The consultant in me had seen an academic opportunity.

The dad in me had wanted his daughters to get ahead.

But now I was looking at two disappointed teenagers who had spent much of their summer studying.

And I had to ask myself whether I’d been focused on the right things.

Two Daughters. Two Different Decisions.

What happened next turned out to be the most important part of the experience.

One of my daughters was struggling with the pace and demands of Honors Geometry.

But the decision to drop the course wasn’t something I made for her.

We talked about it.

We discussed where things stood and whether continuing made sense.

Together, we decided that dropping the course was the better choice.

I didn’t want her to feel that changing direction meant she had failed. Sometimes the more thoughtful decision is recognizing that a particular plan isn’t working and making an adjustment.

My other daughter faced a different decision.

She wanted to continue.

She wanted to finish what she had started.

And I respected that.

I didn’t pressure her to drop the course simply because her sister had.

She stayed, completed Honors Geometry, and earned a B.

Was that the outcome I’d originally hoped for?

Not exactly.

Was dropping the course what I’d envisioned for her sister?

Certainly not.

But looking back, I’m glad I was able to adjust to the circumstances rather than insist that both daughters follow the original plan.

One needed a change in direction.

The other wanted to keep going.

My job wasn’t to make their decisions identical. It was to help each of them make the decision that made sense for her.

That’s something I knew as an education consultant.

That summer, I had to learn it again as a dad.

The Mistake Wasn’t Honors Geometry

I want to be clear about something.

Taking Honors Geometry over the summer wasn’t inherently a bad decision.

For a student who’s academically prepared, motivated, comfortable with the pace, and genuinely interested in the challenge, an accelerated course can be a great opportunity.

And completing a difficult course with a B isn’t a failure.

The mistake wasn’t that I considered acceleration.

The mistake was that I became too focused on what acceleration could accomplish and not focused enough on what it would demand from each daughter.

I was thinking about what they could do.

I should have spent more time thinking about what they should do.

Those are very different questions.

I also learned that a good academic plan isn’t necessarily one that unfolds exactly as expected.

Sometimes the better measure of a plan is whether you’re willing to change it when you learn something new.

That doesn’t mean abandoning every difficult course when things get uncomfortable.

Students need challenges. They need to develop resilience. They need opportunities to work through material that doesn’t come easily.

But there’s a difference between encouraging a student through a worthwhile challenge and continuing with a plan simply because it was the original plan.

And as parents, we need to recognize that difference.

Five Questions I’d Ask Before Making This Decision Again

If another parent asked me today whether their child should take an accelerated summer course, I wouldn’t automatically say yes.

I wouldn’t automatically say no, either.

I’d start with the student.

And I’d ask five questions.

1. Is my child academically ready?

Not just capable of surviving the course.

Actually prepared to learn the material at an accelerated pace.

There’s a difference between being able to get through a class and being in a position to benefit from it.

2. Does my child actually want this challenge?

This matters more than parents sometimes realize.

There’s a big difference between a student saying, “I want to take this course,” and a parent saying, “I think my child should take this course.”

Ideally, the student understands what the commitment involves and has a meaningful voice in the decision.

3. What are we trying to accomplish?

Does acceleration create an opportunity for more advanced coursework later?

Does it solve a scheduling problem?

Does it allow a student to explore a genuine academic interest?

Or are we simply trying to get ahead because getting ahead feels like progress?

That last motivation deserves a closer look.

4. What’s the cost?

And I’m not just talking about tuition.

What’s the cost in time?

Stress?

Sleep?

Family time?

Confidence?

The chance to enjoy being a teenager during the summer?

Watching my daughters study day after day made this question a lot more real for me.

Academic acceleration can create opportunities, but those opportunities come with trade-offs.

5. What happens if the plan doesn’t work?

This may be the most important question of all.

Parents tend to build academic plans around the assumption that things will go well.

Of course we do.

But good planning also means considering what happens when reality doesn’t match expectations.

Can the student change direction without feeling like a failure?

Can the family have an honest conversation about whether continuing makes sense?

Can we recognize that two students facing similar circumstances may reasonably make different choices?

I wish I’d thought more carefully about those questions before the summer began.

What This Changed About Freshman Year

The experience didn’t convince me that academic rigor doesn’t matter.

It does.

I still want my daughters to challenge themselves, work hard, and build strong academic foundations.

But I’m approaching their freshman-year plans with a different question in mind.

Instead of asking:

How rigorous can we make this schedule?

I’m asking:

What’s the appropriate level of rigor for this particular student right now?

That distinction matters.

My daughters don’t need identical academic plans just because they’re twins.

They don’t need identical courses.

They don’t need identical extracurricular activities.

And they certainly don’t need to arrive at the same destination by following the same route.

One may eventually gravitate toward a particular academic interest while the other heads in a completely different direction.

Maybe they’ll discover some shared interests along the way.

Maybe they won’t.

Right now, I’m not trying to predict the answers.

I’m trying to give each of them enough room to discover them.

That also means resisting the temptation to turn ninth grade into a four-year exercise in maximizing their college applications.

I’m not building their college lists yet.

I’m not obsessing over rankings.

I’m not trying to manufacture perfect résumés.

And I’m not assuming that the hardest available course is automatically the best choice.

We’ve got time.

Four years, in fact.

I’d rather use those years to learn who my daughters are than spend them trying to turn them into idealized college applicants.

If you’re weighing similar decisions for your own freshman, I’ve also put together a practical guide on how many AP and Honors classes a freshman should take, including a free worksheet to help families find the right balance.

The Most Valuable Part of Getting It Wrong

Here’s something I didn’t expect.

Looking back, I’m actually glad this lesson came early.

Not because I wanted either daughter to struggle.

I didn’t.

And not because the outcomes were what I’d hoped for.

They weren’t.

But because I had an opportunity to see how my thinking needed to change before the stakes became much higher.

I went into the summer with one plan for both daughters.

I came out of it understanding more clearly why each of them needed her own.

One daughter and I decided that stepping away from Honors Geometry was the right move.

The other decided she wanted to finish, and I supported her.

Neither decision matched the neat academic roadmap I’d initially imagined.

But both taught me something.

Being a good parent doesn’t mean having the perfect plan. Sometimes it means knowing when to let go of the plan you made.

That’s what I want MaddKatt to be about.

Not a perfect family executing a flawless college-prep strategy.

Not an education consultant pretending he has all the answers.

But a real-time account of trying to make thoughtful decisions, getting some of them wrong, listening to my daughters, and adjusting as we go.

The consultant in me will continue to bring experience to the table.

The dad in me will continue to bring hopes, worries, and probably a little too much enthusiasm for academic planning.

I’m still learning how to balance the two.

Because maybe the real purpose of these four years isn’t figuring out how to get my daughters into the “right” college.

Maybe it’s figuring out how to help each of them become the person who’s ready for whatever comes next.

A Resource for Parents

If you’re weighing whether your freshman should take honors or advanced classes, College Board’s guide to high school classes colleges look for is a useful starting point. But as I learned with my twins, the goal isn’t simply to choose the most challenging schedule. It’s to find the right level of challenge for the student sitting in front of you.


Follow the Decisions

Two daughters. Two different paths. One dad learning as we go.

I’m an education consultant with 15 years of experience helping families navigate high school and college preparation. Now I’m doing it with my own twin daughters—and discovering that being the dad is a little different from being the consultant.

MaddKatt is where I share the decisions we’re making, the lessons we’re learning, and the occasional reminder that even someone who does this for a living doesn’t have all the answers.

Want to follow along? Join Follow the Decisions for occasional notes from our journey—the everyday moments, unexpected turns, and things worth sharing along the way.

As a welcome gift, I’ll send you The Freshman-Year Reality Check: 10 Conversations Worth Having With Your High Schooler.

By subscribing, you agree to receive occasional MaddKatt email updates. Your email address will be processed by MailerLite. Unsubscribe anytime. See our Privacy Policy.

Dad
Dad

I'm the dad behind MaddKatt, an education consultant with 15 years of experience in academic counseling, college admissions, and test preparation. Now I'm navigating high school and college prep with my twin daughters, Madd and Katt, and sharing what I'm learning along the way—both as a consultant and as a parent.

Articles: 22

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *