Should Your High Schooler Start a Club? What Parents Need to Know

Starting a high school club can be a great leadership opportunity. But is it the right extracurricular activity for your teenager? Here’s how to decide without turning college preparation into another source of pressure.

I had what I thought was a pretty good idea.

My twin daughters were starting high school, and I suggested that they consider starting a club.

After all, I’ve spent 15 years in education consulting. I’ve talked with plenty of families about extracurricular activities, leadership opportunities, and preparing for college. I understand why taking initiative can be valuable.

There was just one small problem.

My daughters weren’t particularly interested in my idea.

If you’ve read my Journey article, “I Wanted My Twins to Start a High School Club. They Had Other Ideas,” you already know how that went.

The education consultant in me could explain all the potential benefits. The dad in me had to accept that a perfectly reasonable suggestion wasn’t necessarily the right one for my kids.

That experience got me thinking about a question I hear from parents all the time:

Should my high schooler start a club, or is joining an existing club enough?

The answer is probably less complicated than we parents make it.

Diverse group of high school students collaborating around a table during a school club meeting.
Leadership doesn’t always mean starting something new. Sometimes it begins with showing up, contributing, and finding where you belong.

Does Starting a High School Club Help With College Admissions?

Let’s address the college admissions question first, because I suspect it’s what brings many parents here.

Starting a club can demonstrate initiative, organization, leadership, and a willingness to bring people together. Those are all worthwhile qualities.

But here’s the important distinction:

Starting a club isn’t automatically more impressive than participating meaningfully in an existing one.

A student who starts a club, holds a couple of meetings, and loses interest hasn’t necessarily demonstrated more than a student who spends three years helping an established organization grow.

In fact, some colleges are pretty clear about this.

MIT Admissions encourages students to choose extracurricular activities based on what genuinely interests and challenges them, rather than what they think will look impressive on an application.

Yale’s admissions office also discusses the importance of meaningful involvement and a student’s actual contribution to an activity.

Now, MIT and Yale don’t speak for every college. Admissions practices vary, and no single activity guarantees an advantage.

Still, the larger lesson is worth remembering.

A leadership title is nice. Having something meaningful to show for it is better.

And sometimes a student can make a bigger contribution by joining something that’s already working.

When Starting a Club Makes Sense

I’m not against students starting clubs. Far from it.

I’ve seen how valuable it can be when a teenager takes an idea and turns it into something real.

But I would look for three things before encouraging a student to take that step.

1. There’s a Genuine Interest

Maybe your teenager loves environmental science, photography, chess, coding, or community service.

They’ve looked at the school’s existing clubs, and nothing quite fits.

That’s a reasonable starting point.

The key is that the interest belongs to the student.

If the only reason for starting a club is that a parent thinks it will strengthen a college application, I’d reconsider.

2. There’s a Purpose Beyond the Title

A club needs something to do.

Not just a name. Not just a president. Not just a page in the yearbook.

What will members actually work on?

Could a photography club organize student exhibitions? Could an environmental club help reduce waste at school? Could a tutoring club provide regular academic support?

It doesn’t need to be a world-changing mission.

But there should be a reason for the club to exist.

3. Your Teenager Is Willing to Do the Work

This is the part that doesn’t always make it into the enthusiastic conversation about starting a club.

Someone has to recruit members, communicate with a faculty adviser, plan meetings, and keep things moving.

And yes, sometimes that means sending reminders to people who don’t respond.

Welcome to leadership.

Starting a club can be a terrific experience for a student who’s ready for that responsibility.

For a freshman who’s still figuring out high school, it might be one more thing on an already full plate.

When Joining an Existing Club Is the Better Choice

Here’s something I wish more parents would consider.

Joining a club isn’t settling.

Sometimes it’s the smartest way for a student to explore an interest without immediately taking on the responsibility of leading an organization.

An existing club gives teenagers a chance to meet people, understand how a group operates, and decide whether they actually enjoy the activity.

And leadership doesn’t have to begin with a title.

A student can organize an event, mentor younger members, manage a project, or solve a problem without being the founder or president.

Over time, those contributions can become much more meaningful than a title on its own.

My advice? Before suggesting that your teenager start something new, ask whether there’s already a group where they could make a real contribution.

There might be more opportunity there than either of you realizes.

What If Your Freshman Doesn’t Know What They Want to Do?

This is where I think parents sometimes get ahead of themselves.

Freshman year is a transition.

Students are adjusting to new classes, new expectations, new friendships, and a very different daily schedule.

Some teenagers arrive with clear interests and a plan.

Others need time.

Both are normal.

If your freshman doesn’t know which extracurricular activities to pursue, I’d encourage exploration rather than immediate commitment.

Try attending a few club meetings. Talk with older students. Explore an activity outside school. Volunteer somewhere that interests them.

And don’t overlook responsibilities that aren’t part of an official school club.

The Common App recognizes a broad range of activities, including employment, hobbies, community involvement, and family responsibilities.

Not every meaningful experience comes with a club membership.

I would rather see a freshman spend a semester discovering something they genuinely enjoy than rush into three organizations simply because their parents are worried about college admissions.

Four years is a long time.

There’s room to explore.

How Parents Can Help Without Taking Over

This is the section I probably need to reread myself.

As parents, we can see possibilities our teenagers haven’t considered yet.

That’s one of the benefits of experience.

But there’s a difference between helping a student recognize an opportunity and deciding which opportunity they should pursue.

Here are a few things I’d recommend.

Ask questions before offering solutions.

Instead of saying, “You should start a club,” try asking, “Is there anything you wish your school offered?”

You might discover an interest you didn’t know existed.

Or you might discover that your teenager is perfectly happy with the opportunities already available.

Help them understand their options.

If they’re interested in starting a club, help them find the school’s requirements. Many schools have procedures involving faculty advisers, student interest, or administrative approval.

But let your teenager make the inquiries.

They’ll learn more by sending that email themselves.

Discuss the time commitment.

A student taking challenging courses, participating in sports, or managing other responsibilities may not have time to launch and maintain another activity.

That’s not a lack of ambition.

That’s learning to make choices.

Resist the urge to turn every interest into a college admissions strategy.

This one is tough, especially for parents who have spent time thinking about the admissions process.

But teenagers deserve opportunities to do things simply because they enjoy them.

Not everything needs to become a résumé line.

A Practical Club Decision Checklist for Parents and Students

Before your high schooler starts a club, sit down together and work through these questions.

There’s no need to turn this into an interrogation. A conversation over dinner works just fine.

Interest and Motivation

  • Is this something my teenager genuinely wants to pursue?
  • Can they explain why the club should exist?
  • Would they still be interested if starting it offered no college admissions advantage?

Existing Opportunities

  • Have we reviewed the clubs already available at school?
  • Could an existing club provide a similar experience?
  • Has my teenager attended a meeting or talked with current members?

Time and Responsibility

  • Does my teenager have enough time alongside schoolwork and other commitments?
  • Are they willing to organize meetings, recruit members, and follow through?
  • Do they understand the school’s requirements for starting a club?

Long-Term Value

  • Is there a realistic goal for the club’s first semester?
  • Could the club provide something useful or enjoyable for other students?
  • Is my teenager interested in the work, not just the leadership title?

Here’s how I’d use this checklist: If several answers are “no” or “I’m not sure,” that doesn’t mean your teenager should abandon the idea. It may simply mean they’re better off exploring first.

And if the answers point toward joining an existing club instead, that’s a perfectly good outcome.

What I Would Tell a Freshman About Extracurricular Activities

If a ninth grader asked me whether they should start a club to improve their chances of getting into college, I’d probably say something like this:

Don’t start with the college application.

Start with what interests you.

Find a few activities you enjoy. Give yourself enough time to see whether those interests stick. Look for opportunities to contribute, learn something, and work with other people.

If you eventually notice something missing at your school and want to create it, wonderful.

Start the club.

But if you find an existing organization where you’re learning, helping, and growing, that’s valuable too.

And if your interests change between freshman and sophomore year?

That’s okay.

You’re allowed to figure things out.

What My Twins Are Teaching Me About This

When I suggested that Madd and Katt start a club, I was looking at the opportunity through the lens of someone who’s worked in education consulting for 15 years.

I could see the possible benefits.

They were looking at it through their own interests and priorities.

And that’s the perspective I needed to hear.

I still believe extracurricular activities matter. They can help teenagers build friendships, develop confidence, discover interests, and learn to take responsibility.

But I’ve become more conscious of the difference between encouraging an opportunity and pushing an agenda.

My daughters don’t need to follow the extracurricular path I would have chosen for them.

They need to find paths that make sense for who they are.

That’s a harder lesson for a parent than it sounds.

Especially when the parent happens to think he has some pretty good ideas.

The Bottom Line

So, should your high schooler start a club?

Yes—if there’s a genuine interest, a worthwhile purpose, and a willingness to do the work.

If not, joining an existing club, volunteering, working, pursuing a personal project, or exploring other interests can be just as worthwhile.

The goal isn’t to manufacture a leadership title for a future college application.

It’s to help your teenager become someone who knows what interests them, follows through on commitments, and contributes in ways that matter.

And sometimes our most useful job as parents is to offer a suggestion, listen to the response, and let our teenagers make the decision.

I’m still working on that last part.

Starting a club is only one part of extracurricular planning. If you’re wondering how many activities your teenager should pursue, read our guide: How Many Extracurricular Activities Do You Need for College?


Want to see how this conversation played out in my own house? Read my Journey story, “I Wanted My Twins to Start a High School Club. They Had Other Ideas.”

At MaddKatt, I’m documenting what happens when 15 years of education consulting experience meets the very real experience of guiding my own twin daughters through high school.

Two daughters. Two paths. One journey to college.


Follow the Decisions

Two daughters. Two different paths. One dad learning as we go.

I’m an education consultant with 15 years of experience helping families navigate high school and college preparation. Now I’m doing it with my own twin daughters—and discovering that being the dad is a little different from being the consultant.

MaddKatt is where I share the decisions we’re making, the lessons we’re learning, and the occasional reminder that even someone who does this for a living doesn’t have all the answers.

Want to follow along? Join Follow the Decisions for occasional notes from our journey—the everyday moments, unexpected turns, and things worth sharing along the way.

As a welcome gift, I’ll send you The Freshman-Year Reality Check: 10 Conversations Worth Having With Your High Schooler.

By subscribing, you agree to receive occasional MaddKatt email updates. Your email address will be processed by MailerLite. Unsubscribe anytime. See our Privacy Policy.

Dad
Dad

I'm the dad behind MaddKatt, an education consultant with 15 years of experience in academic counseling, college admissions, and test preparation. Now I'm navigating high school and college prep with my twin daughters, Madd and Katt, and sharing what I'm learning along the way—both as a consultant and as a parent.

Articles: 22

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *