The Freshman-Year Pivot: Why My Daughter Doesn’t Have to Know What She Wants to Be Yet

Does a high school freshman need to know what they want to study in college? When one of my twins began questioning her interest in engineering after a difficult Honors Geometry experience, I learned an important lesson about letting teenagers explore their own paths.

One of my twin daughters thought she might want to become an engineer. Then came Honors Geometry, a difficult decision, and a conversation that reminded me what freshman year is really supposed to be about.

Does a high school freshman really need to choose a college major before they’ve even started exploring their interests?

As an education consultant with 15 years of experience helping students and families navigate college admissions, I know how tempting it can be to start planning early.

As a dad raising twin daughters, I’m learning that planning ahead and expecting a teenager to have her future figured out are two very different things.

You would think my professional experience would make me pretty good at knowing when to offer advice and when to just be a dad.

You would think.

If you’ve been following our journey, you know that I encouraged both of my twin daughters to take Honors Geometry over the summer before their freshman year of high school.

I thought they could handle the challenge. I thought getting ahead in math would give them more flexibility when choosing courses later in high school.

As it turned out, my daughters had two very different experiences.

One stuck with the course, worked through the challenges, and finished with a B.

The other decided to drop it.

I’ve already written about what happened when I pushed my twins into Honors Geometry and what that experience taught me about the difference between being an education consultant and being a dad.

But what I didn’t fully realize at the time was that dropping Honors Geometry might have affected more than one daughter’s summer schedule.

She had been interested in engineering. She had enjoyed engineering electives in middle school and had started thinking about engineering as a possible college major.

And now, after struggling with Honors Geometry, I wondered whether she was beginning to question that possibility.

As her dad, I wanted her to know that one difficult class didn’t define what she could accomplish.

As an education consultant, I had some questions of my own.

But the biggest surprise came later, when I discovered that the issue wasn’t simply whether she could pursue engineering.

It was whether she felt she was allowed to change her mind.

When Dropping a Class Feels Like Something Bigger

After my daughter dropped Honors Geometry, I sensed that she was dealing with more than just disappointment about the class.

I think part of her felt that she had fallen short of something she had hoped to accomplish.

And I wondered whether another part of her was beginning to question her interest in engineering.

If Honors Geometry had been stressful, what did that mean for a future that might involve a lot more math?

Was engineering still something she could do?

Was it something she should do?

I don’t know exactly how much of that was going through her mind at the time. But those questions were certainly going through mine.

And as much as I wanted to reassure her, I knew there was more to the conversation than simply telling her everything would be fine.

The Dad and the Consultant Had Different Reactions

My first reaction as a dad was simple.

It’s okay.

Dropping one summer class doesn’t define you. It doesn’t determine your intelligence, your abilities, or what you can accomplish later.

I wanted her to know that I believed in her and that she could still pursue engineering—or anything else she was interested in.

And I meant every word.

But the consultant in me had some questions.

Engineering programs generally require a strong foundation in math. What if she continued to find advanced math stressful? What if the day-to-day work of studying engineering wasn’t something she would enjoy?

Those seemed like reasonable questions to consider.

The problem was that I didn’t know how to raise them without sending the wrong message.

I didn’t want her to hear, “Maybe engineering isn’t for you.”

I especially didn’t want her to think, “Dad doesn’t believe I’m good enough.”

There is a big difference between helping a teenager think realistically about a possible career and making that teenager feel like you’ve already decided what she can or cannot do.

I was afraid of crossing that line.

So, for a while, I didn’t push the conversation.

Which, if you know anything about education consultants, may have been an accomplishment in itself.

The Conversation I Almost Didn’t Have

Eventually, as some time passed, we talked more about engineering.

Not in one dramatic, life-changing conversation.

Just several conversations over time.

And something interesting came out of them.

My daughter wasn’t actually 100% committed to engineering.

She had enjoyed those middle school electives. Engineering sounded interesting. She could imagine herself pursuing it.

But that was about as far as it went.

She was exploring an idea, not announcing a lifelong commitment.

Somewhere along the way, though, she had started to feel as if saying she was interested in engineering meant she was supposed to stick with it.

Changing her mind felt like backing out.

And backing out didn’t feel right.

That caught me off guard.

I had been worried about whether she was questioning her ability to pursue engineering.

What I hadn’t fully appreciated was that she might also be questioning whether she had permission to pursue something else.

Those are two very different concerns.

And I realized I needed to be careful not to turn a passing interest into an expectation simply because I was eager to help her plan ahead.

A Freshman-Year Interest Is Not a Lifetime Contract

In an ideal world, wouldn’t it be nice if every freshman entered high school knowing exactly what they wanted to study in college?

They would choose the right courses, join the right clubs, pursue the right activities, and build a perfectly consistent four-year plan.

College preparation would be so much easier.

For the parents, anyway.

But that’s not how most teenagers work.

And honestly, I’m not sure that’s how we should want them to work.

At 14 or 15, students are still discovering what interests them, what challenges them, what they’re good at, and what kind of work they might enjoy.

Sometimes they discover those things by trying something new.

Sometimes they discover them by struggling.

And sometimes they discover them by realizing that something they once thought they wanted isn’t quite what they imagined.

None of those experiences is a failure.

They’re information.

My daughter enjoyed engineering electives in middle school. That’s useful information.

She found Honors Geometry more challenging than expected. That’s useful information, too.

Neither experience, by itself, should decide her future.

A difficult math class doesn’t automatically close the door on engineering.

And enjoying a few engineering electives doesn’t mean she has to walk through that door.

She is allowed to keep exploring. For families wondering where to begin, BigFuture’s career exploration resources offer students a way to learn about different career possibilities without having to commit to one.

The Difference Between Pivoting and Giving Up

I think this is where parents—including me—can get a little too caught up in the idea of commitment.

We want our children to develop perseverance.

We don’t want them quitting every time something becomes difficult.

And we certainly don’t want them walking away from opportunities simply because they’re uncomfortable.

Those are reasonable concerns.

But there’s a difference between giving up on something because it’s hard and reconsidering something because you’re learning more about yourself.

The tricky part is that, from the outside, those two things can look similar.

A student who decides not to pursue engineering might be avoiding a challenge.

Or that student might be discovering a stronger interest in another field.

Or, as in my daughter’s case, she might not be ready to decide at all.

That’s why I think the conversation matters more than the label.

Instead of immediately asking, “Are you still going to pursue engineering?” maybe the better questions are:

  • What did you enjoy about those engineering classes?
  • What parts were less interesting?
  • Is engineering something you still want to explore?
  • Are there other subjects or careers you’re curious about?
  • What would you like to try next?

Those questions leave room for curiosity.

They also leave room for honesty.

And perhaps most importantly, they don’t make a teenager feel that changing direction means disappointing a parent.

So, Is She Still Interested in Engineering?

Yes.

At least enough that she hasn’t ruled it out.

And I’m glad.

Not because I need her to become an engineer, but because I don’t want one difficult summer course to convince her that a possibility is gone forever.

At the same time, she’s decided to explore other interests.

I’m glad about that, too.

She doesn’t need to make a final decision right now.

She can take classes, participate in activities, discover new subjects, and see where her interests lead.

If engineering continues to appeal to her, we can revisit what academic preparation she might need and how she can build her confidence in math.

If something else captures her attention, we can explore that path instead.

And if she changes her mind again?

Well, I suppose I’ll have to survive another pivot.

Yarn, crochet hooks, a model rocket, and a wooden race car on a table
Different interests, different possibilities. Freshman year is a time to explore—not to have everything figured out.

Meanwhile, Her Twin Has a Different Approach

And then there’s my other daughter.

The one who stayed in Honors Geometry and finished with a B.

When it comes to what she wants to study in college or do for a career, she has no idea.

Not a clue.

No particular college major. No carefully mapped-out career path.

And you know what?

That’s okay, too.

One daughter has an interest she’s keeping open while exploring alternatives.

The other is starting with a relatively blank slate.

Same parents. Same household. Same stage of life.

Two completely different approaches to figuring out the future.

Which is a pretty good reminder of why I started documenting this journey in the first place.

There isn’t one perfect way to navigate high school.

And there certainly isn’t one timeline that works for every teenager.

My job isn’t to make sure both girls arrive at freshman year with a career plan.

It’s to help them become curious, capable young people who feel comfortable exploring their options.

That’s a different kind of preparation.

And probably a more important one right now.

What This Experience Is Teaching Me as a Dad

I’ve spent years advising families about college preparation.

I know that some decisions matter earlier than others.

I know that students interested in certain majors may need to think carefully about course sequences, especially in subjects like math and science.

I’m not going to pretend those practical considerations disappear just because I want my daughters to feel less pressure.

They don’t.

For families trying to find that balance, I’ve also written a parent’s guide to choosing AP and Honors classes for freshman year, including a worksheet to help think through course decisions.

But I am learning that there’s a difference between keeping doors open and making a teenager feel she has already chosen which door to walk through.

I can help my daughter understand what pursuing engineering might involve without expecting her to commit to it.

I can encourage her to challenge herself without making every academic setback feel like a verdict on her future.

And I can remind both my daughters that exploring different possibilities isn’t a distraction from college preparation.

It is part of college preparation.

Maybe that’s the biggest pivot happening in our house right now.

Not my daughter’s potential change in direction.

Mine.

I’m learning to spend a little less time trying to predict where my daughters will end up and a little more time helping them figure out who they’re becoming.

It’s Okay to Pivot

If you’re the parent of a freshman who already knows what they want to do, that’s wonderful.

Encourage that interest. Help them explore it. Give them opportunities to see whether it continues to grow.

But don’t make them feel trapped by it.

And if your freshman has absolutely no idea what they want to do?

That’s okay, too.

There are classes to take, clubs to try, people to meet, and interests they haven’t discovered yet.

There will be plenty of opportunities to make decisions as they learn more about themselves.

Of course, some academic choices do require planning, and not every change in direction is equally easy at every stage. That’s a reason to stay informed and keep options open—not a reason to demand certainty from a 14-year-old.

I don’t believe there’s a single deadline by which a teenager must have everything figured out.

There will be pivots along the way.

Some small.

Some big.

Some that make perfect sense to us as parents.

And some that leave us wondering what happened to the plan we thought we had.

I’m beginning to think that’s exactly what this journey is supposed to look like.

Two daughters. Two paths. And plenty of room to change direction.

Want to help your freshman explore what’s next without pushing them to choose a major? I put together a practical parent’s guide with five ways to explore career interests, conversation starters, and a free worksheet: How to Help Your Freshman Explore Careers Without Choosing a College Major.


Follow the Decisions

Two daughters. Two different paths. One dad learning as we go.

I’m an education consultant with 15 years of experience helping families navigate high school and college preparation. Now I’m doing it with my own twin daughters—and discovering that being the dad is a little different from being the consultant.

MaddKatt is where I share the decisions we’re making, the lessons we’re learning, and the occasional reminder that even someone who does this for a living doesn’t have all the answers.

Want to follow along? Join Follow the Decisions for occasional notes from our journey—the everyday moments, unexpected turns, and things worth sharing along the way.

As a welcome gift, I’ll send you The Freshman-Year Reality Check: 10 Conversations Worth Having With Your High Schooler.

By subscribing, you agree to receive occasional MaddKatt email updates. Your email address will be processed by MailerLite. Unsubscribe anytime. See our Privacy Policy.

Dad
Dad

I'm the dad behind MaddKatt, an education consultant with 15 years of experience in academic counseling, college admissions, and test preparation. Now I'm navigating high school and college prep with my twin daughters, Madd and Katt, and sharing what I'm learning along the way—both as a consultant and as a parent.

Articles: 22

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *